Sep 19, 2014 kelley blue book is the most popular blue book car value guide among dealers, being the longest running guide of all three. Kelley blue book kbb is an automotive shopping site. The main difference between kelley blue book and nada tradein value is the data they use kelley blue book gathers information to determine pricing by using information from. This is an as is value that does not include any warranties. Nada value means nothing to the dealer i work at, its not the source we use to determine a base value for a vehicle. The kelley blue book also gathers its data from a number of different sources. Kelley blue book is the most popular blue book car value guide among dealers, being the longest running guide of all three. The final sales price depends on the cars actual condition and local market factors. Before purchasing a used car, it is necessary for consumers to check the current value of the used car they choose. Blue book, or black book, or nada value, or whatever you use, is only a guideline. Oct 20, 2019 these two guide solutions that are mainly the highlight of this article are the nada rv vs kelley blue book rv. The issue i had as a manager when dealing with a customer who came in with the kbb value was that they always thought the value was the lowest amount.
Nada guides is a comprehensive vehiclelisting website that publishes blue book type specifications, research material, and pricing information on boats and personal watercraft as well as other types of vehicles. The nada blue book is the official retail price listing for the national automobile dealers association, a national trade group that. In order to post prices they use an algorithm that takes prices posted on autotrader which is the most widely used car selling site on the internet and owned by. Apr 05, 2020 is kelley blue book or nada more accurate april 5, 2020 nada black book and kelley blue 10 s to ing a car kelley car dealer kelley blue book kelley blue book canada an easier way kelley blue book vs nada s. Problem is, when i check the pricing on kelley blue book website, it says that the car is overpriced by 1200 dollars. Get used car, truck and suv values with edmunds car value appraisal tool. They will use a number of resources, namely kelley blue book and nada.
Kelley blue book is a great tool to get a solid understanding of the value of your used vehicle. Or, similar to the way the nada guides work, you can also search. How accurate are kelly blue book values for motorcycles. Sep 01, 20 kelley blue book gives users the option to list the condition of the vehicle on a range from excellent to poor, which will adjust the price and value, resulting in a more accurate quote. Many dealers utilize the kelley blue book guide prices for used vehicles, and dealers and customers negotiate the actual price of a vehicle downward from that level. The nada pricing guides can be trusted and reliable. The nada rv pricing guide is the most accurate one youll find for rv values, however, its not always the easiest one to use. For over 80 years now, it has helped dealers find the overall value of a used car by factoring in the cars overall condition, mileage, any builtin components and the location where the car is located. Feb 28, 2020 nada pricing is often higher than kelley blue book since the algorithm has a standard that calls for all tradeins to be in very clean condition.
Nada and kelley blue book are both accurate and reliable. Nada guides also provides data to banks, finance companies, insurance companies, and government agencies. Nadaguides national appraisal guides and kelley blue book both have a long. Both the guides serve buyers and sellers with lots of vehicle types, price calculation, and also vehicle values according to the proprietary methods. The easiest way to find a considerate price is to check kbb kelley blue book or nada national automobile dealers association. These two guide solutions that are mainly the highlight of this article are the nada rv vs kelley blue book rv. As a result, you may need to adjust nada prices down. The industry consensus is that data from nada guides tends to be more accurate. The nada blue book is the official retail price listing for the national automobile dealers association, a national trade group that incorporates thousands of car dealers.
The reason for this is that nada assumes the vehicle to be in relatively good condition which in turn has earned kelley blue book the reputation for more accurately reflecting the buyers objective. In this article, we will look into these two books separately and then conclude which one of them is the most accurate and would probably give correct and right values to the buyers or sellers who are constantly looking for an answer. Since 1926, kelley blue book has been one of the bestknown names in the auto industry. Nadaguides national appraisal guides and kelley blue book both have a long history devoted to providing consumers and businesses with accurate vehicle pricing information. The result has been an amped up demand and kelley blue book is trying to track that uptick. The nada guides are a comprehensive vehiclelisting website that publishes blue book type specifications, research material, and pricing information on boats and personal watercraft as well as other types of vehicles. Nov 25, 2019 ask any used car dealer what the most accurate guide book is and you will likely get very different answers depending on what part of the country you are located in. Dealers can use both kelly blue book and nada values depending on their preference.
Dealers use kelly blue book to establish the value of tradeins as well as comparing numbers to set their lot prices. Just go to the homepage and click on the boats for sale tab. May 02, 2019 you need to understand what the book actually is. The guides issued by the national automotive dealers association use dealer sales prices which are not exactly helpful if you are buying or selling a car through a private. Proudly serving buyers and sellers of various vehicle types, both companies calculate and publish vehicle values based on proprietary methods. Ask any used car dealer what the most accurate guide book is and you will likely get very different answers depending on what part of the country you are located in. We attempt to create the most accurate, marketreflective, unbiased vehicle. Since the kelley blue book specifies only on automobiles, learning how to use your other resources effectively is very important. In this article, we will be taking a closer look at each of the websites available for you to find accurate prices of both rvs and travel trailers.
Nada guide, black book and kelley blue book compared autoblog. Keep in mind that nada usually calculates a value that is higher than kelley blue book. Selling privately, youre unlikely to get the kelley blue book trade in price, but that doesnt mean youre getting a bad deal, simply a fair market price. Nada is short for the national automobile dealers association. It is a lot more accurate and its what the dealers will use if they are valuing your bike for tradeinsale in their showroom. Mar 30, 2020 well, this is also not super accurate.
While completing research via a service like kelley blue book or can give. Nada guides vs kelley blue book nada guides and kelley blue book have an extensive history in providing organizations and customers with accurate vehicle pricing and information. New car prices and used car book values nadaguides. I dont get why kelly blue book is lowballing the value of my car by thousands more than nada is.
But if you check nada that price will be right on nadas or real close. Access free kelley blue book nada guide kelley blue book nada guide. Kbb always highballs and nada always lowballs, so keep that in mind too. But i do believe i give some pretty good reasons why you should use nada over kbb. The name itself originates from an old registry which lists those of high society and was named the blue book.
Nada vs kelley blue book nada blue book, nada guide. A dealer paying blue book for a tradein is either going to retail the car more profit or push it back. Whether you use the kelley blue book guide or prefer, the book pricing of vehicles can be a little misleading. For example i have seen a truck thats a year or two difference blue book for way different amounts even though there was no changes from those years and in real life they would both sell for the same. Kelley blue book values blue book values kbb vs nadaguides. Nada guides is a comprehensive vehiclelisting website that publishes bluebook type specifications, research material, and pricing information on boats and personal watercraft as well as other types of vehicles. As a result of the economic down turn people are looking for good quality used cars as opposed to new. For almost eighty years, nada guides and kelley blue book have served as a guide for.
While black book is mostly used by dealers, kelley blue book not spelled kelly blue book without the e is mostly used by individuals looking to trade in or sell their vehicles. Get used car values with edmunds car value appraisal tool. Nada blue book does not feature any loan or insurance information on their website. Ask any used car dealer what the most accurate guide book is and you will likely get very different answers depending on what part of the. The most commonly used are the kelly blue book, and the edmunds used price guide. Kelley blue book regularly receives car prices from wholesale auctions, car dealers, rental fleets, auto manufacturers and private party sales. Sep 11, 2016 this is how you properly use kelley blue book to get a real idea of what someone would be willing to pay for your vehicle. Aug 03, 2008 which appraisal service is more accurate, kelly blue book or nada.
How kbb set the prices of used vehicles kbb collects the data of current realworld prices from different sources such as dealers, rental fleets, automotive manufactures, private sales, and car auctions. Kelley and edmunds are always high in their prices. There are two valuable sources for gathering information about the value of your used car. How does the blue book range compare with asking prices at. It uses a sophisticated algorithm to analyze pricing data, historical trends, current economic conditions, time of year, location and industry developments to come up with an accurate value for each. Back to the books, since each of the three value data industry leaders claim to offer the most accurate information and the best deal to buyers and sellers, aol autos decided to investigate by researching the used car values of three different types of vehicles in each of the three books, kelley blue book, black book and the nada guide. Kelley blue book how does it compare to market value. Heres a look at just how trustworthy it is plus a comparison with the competition. Add to that the ever increasing quality of cars mainly from japan and korea which has made the used car option more reasonable than ever. Blue book car value guide nada blue book, nada guide. Nada rv vs kelley blue book which is better more accurate. The nada used car price guide is a set of consumer reports similar to the kelley blue book and to the edmunds guide. Kelley blue book and edmunds are two of the most well known used car pricing guides in the united states.
Sep 21, 2009 problem is, when i check the pricing on kelley blue book website, it says that the car is overpriced by 1200 dollars. Let me explain what goes into these price guidelines. The main difference between kelley blue book and nada tradein value is the data they use. Research the latest new car prices, deals, used car values, specs and more. How reliable is the nada used car price guide carsdirect. It is one of many tools used by car dealers to determine car values for their inventory. Which appraisal service is more accurate, kelly blue book or nada. Nada pricing is often higher than kelley blue book since the algorithm has a standard that calls for all tradeins to be in very clean condition.
Jun 20, 2019 kelley blue book is a great tool to get a solid understanding of the value of your used vehicle. Nada guides and kelley blue book have an extensive history in providing organizations and customers with accurate vehicle pricing and information. Download free nada price guide used cars nada price guide used cars used car pricing how do i know what is the actual fair market value of my car kelly blue book, nada, private seller or black book which is the true. Any item is only worth as much as you can find someone to buy it for. Kelley blue book is a company that was founded in 1926. While completing research via a service like kelley blue book or can give you a reasonable idea of your vehicles tradein, private party or retail value, used car pricing can vary significantly from city.
Boat type, make, price, length, year, and location can all be set as parameters. How accurate is kelley blue book pricing the dis disney. Is kelley blue book or nada more accurate april 5, 2020. Now in adds they will so much off kelley or edmunds. Im not about to pay that much more than what a car is supposedly worth. I want to get the best deal on a truck, but there is a wide difference in the prices from these services. Whether youre trading your vehicle in at a dealer or planning to. I dont get why kellyblue book is lowballing the value of my car by thousands more than nada is. Kelley blue book or kbb is a respected used car price guide often quoted by used car dealers to demonstrate that prices of cars on their lots are fair. Nada guides were designed for dealer members of the. The kelley blue book is the most popular usedcar buying guide.
In 1926, les kelley created the signature kelley blue book. Nada guides is the leader in accurate vehicle pricing and vehicle information. Unlike edmunds, however, kelley values generally cater more toward the dealer. How accurate are they and how do they get their numbers. Kelley blue book kbb is wordwidely known as reputable valuation company that provides trusted guides of car values. The nada website is probably the closest thing to the kelley blue book website when it comes to pricing and value for rvs. But youre more than welcome to watch the video and form your own opinion. Car dealers are experts when it comes to deciding a tradein price. Shop for new cars and new car prices at kelley blue books. What s my motorcycle worth the truth behind kbb 3 ways to determine the fair market value of a vehicle wikihow are kelley blue book values accurate and reliable kelley blue book vs nada s andy mohr auto indiana black book vs kelly blue trade in values fremont motor pany. Kelley blue book gives users the option to list the condition of the vehicle on a range from excellent to poor, which will adjust the price and value, resulting in a more accurate quote. The difference between kelley blue book and nada tradein. My dad who has bought several cars from this used car dealer is going in there with my printout from kelley to ask them why their pricing is so off.
Which appraisal service is more accurate, kelly blue book. Nada numbers come from the auctions and dealer reports. They will use a number of resources, namely kelley blue book and nada tradein value, but they mainly rely on their years of experience appraising cars. Oct 07, 20 kelley blue book gives you a general idea of what you can expect for your vehicle on the private market and can be used as a good starting point for negotiations. The blue book or the nada book is merely a report of what has sold in the last 2 weeks and what it sold for.
Every used car is unique and many factors influence its performance and future maintenance costs. Is kelley blue book or nada more accurate image collections. Kelley blue book vs edmunds used car price guide most individuals buying or selling cars will use mass market guides to help gauge market prices. Here is the assessment to know how accurate and reliable kelley blue book. When it comes to realizing the blue book price when selling a used car outright, sellers often find their expectations are set too high.
Many experts believe edmunds values are more accurate than kbbs. Search and compare hundreds of new car vehicle categories and models. Nada, which is the national automobile dealers association, uses actual retail sales data provided by its member car dealersas there are sometimes large differences in the. In 1918, les kelley, a businessman from arkansas, founded a car dealership with no more than three model t fords. This is how you properly use kelley blue book to get a real idea of what someone would be willing to pay for your vehicle. Blue book car value guide nada guide nada book value. Nada vs kelley blue book car kelley blue book canada an easier way to check out a car s value carbly vin scanner by ambient automotive inc kelley blue book trade in value cars get all information kelley blue book vs car invoice s get all information. The kelley blue book value and nada value are different because they use different algorithms and methods to come to the value of vehicles. Kelley blue book is heavily used on the west coast, black book in the southeast, and nada is more widespread nationally due to its heavy dependency from financial institutions in regards to loan originations. Usually, those who use one are also familiar with the other. Nada has been around for over 80 years and is the premier valuation guide in. Nada also provides data to banks, finance companies, insurance companies, and government agencies. Edmunds and kelly bb are just for consumers so they can get an idea of how to price or buy used vehicles. I have also seen where a truck booked for more then the older years when the opposite is true.
662 447 1040 768 1088 333 348 423 1078 510 1332 1495 539 1228 1018 36 1373 879 943 232 416 1471 662 453 371 90 1061 544 663 1105 180 917 415 259 285 1253 794 183 174 754